Canada Revenue Agency (Re), 2026 OIC 66
Date: 2026-08-27
OIC file number: 5825-02560
Access request number: A-2025-000662.
Summary
The complainant alleged that the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) incorrectly interpreted the scope of the access request. This allegation falls under paragraph 30(1)(f) of the Act. The complainant also alleged that CRA did not search for the records requested and/or that additional records that are responsive to the access request must exist. This allegation falls under paragraph 30(1)(a) of the Act. The request was for records related to CRA’s monitoring, evaluation, or investigation of the conduct of CRA-approved trust companies administering Registered Retirement Savings Plans or Tax-Free Savings Accounts.
The investigation revealed that CRA did not incorrectly interpret the scope of the access request. Rather, CRA used the actual wording of the access request to inform its interpretation of the request and subsequent search for records. The investigation also revealed that the Offices of Primary Interest most likely to have records relevant to the access request under their control searched for records in the appropriate repositories and used appropriate parameters. CRA explained that many of the requested records were related to situations outside of its mandate.
The complaint is not well founded.
Complaint
[1]The complainant alleged that the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) incorrectly interpreted the scope of the access request. The request was for records related to CRA’s monitoring, evaluation, or investigation of the conduct of CRA-approved trust companies administering Registered Retirement Savings Plans (RRSPs) or Tax-Free Savings Accounts (TFSAs). This allegation falls under paragraph 30(1)(f) of the Act.
[2]The complainant also alleged that CRA did not search for the records requested and/or that additional records that are responsive to the above-noted access request must exist. This allegation falls under paragraph 30(1)(a) of the Act.
Investigation
Paragraph 30(1)(f): improper interpretation of scope
[3]The complainant alleged that CRA improperly interpreted the scope of the access request. The full text of the access request is as follows:
[4]Period: between January 1, 2000 and the present date.
[5]Pursuant to the Access to Information Act, I request access to all documents, records, communications, internal memoranda, reports, audits, meeting minutes, correspondence, or policy guidance held by the Canada Revenue Agency between January 1, 2000, and the present that relate to:
[6]The CRA’s monitoring, evaluation, or investigation of the conduct of CRA-approved trust companies administering Registered Retirement Savings Plans (RRSPs) or Tax-Free Savings Accounts (TFSAs), specifically in relation to: Fiduciary duties owed to account holders; Conflict of interest management; Delegation of RRSP/TFSA functions (e.g., foreign exchange services) to affiliated entities; Disclosure of fees, markups, or service charges deducted from trust account assets; Any measures taken to assess whether trustees act in the best interest of the RRSP or TFSA beneficiaries.
[7]Any CRA enforcement actions, investigations, compliance reviews, or disciplinary measures undertaken against RRSP/TFSA trustees for failing to meet fiduciary, loyalty, or transparency obligations.
[8]Any CRA internal or external consultations, studies, risk assessments, or strategy papers on whether trust companies administering registered plans are acting in accordance with the fiduciary principles implied by trust law or required by the structure of a registered plan.
[9]This request includes documents regardless of format (e.g., paper, electronic, briefing notes, legal opinions, audit findings) and regardless of whether the term “fiduciary” is explicitly used, so long as the content pertains to conduct, loyalty, fairness, or conflicts of interest in the administration of RRSP/TFSA trusts.”
[10]CRA explained that it does not approve trust companies and that therefore some of the records sought by the request may be held by other institutions. CRA also represented that qualified investment rules under the Income Tax Act are tax compliance provisions and are not related to the fiduciary duty, loyalty or transparency obligations of trustees. CRA went on to explain that fiduciary duties are the purview of Provincial Trust Law, such as, for example, the province of Ontario’s Trustees Act. CRA explained that those records might be held by other institutions.
[11]CRA represented that it interpreted the access request based on the text it contained. In reviewing the representations provided, the Office of the Information Commissioner (OIC) is satisfied that CRA’s interpretation of the request was reasonable.
[12]In light of the above, the OIC concludes that CRA did not improperly interpret the scope of the access request.
Reasonable Search
[13]CRA was required to conduct a reasonable search for records that fall within the scope of the access request—that is, one or more experienced employees, knowledgeable in the subject matter of the request, must have made reasonable efforts to identify and locate all records reasonably related to the request.
[14]A reasonable search involves a level of effort that would be expected of any fair, sensible person tasked with searching for responsive records where they are likely to be stored.
[15]This search does not have to be perfect. An institution is therefore not required to prove with absolute certainty that further records do not exist. Institutions must however be able to show that they took reasonable steps to identify and locate responsive records.
Did the institution conduct a reasonable search for records?
[16]The OIC examined the responses of the Offices of Primary Interests (OPIs) that were tasked with the search to determine whether they had fulfilled their obligation under the Act to identify records relevant to the access request under their control. CRA’s Compliance Programs Branch (CPB) explained that it sent a request to identify potentially responsive records to its Criminal Investigations Directorate, High Net Worth Compliance Directorate, International and Large Business Directorate, and Small and Medium Enterprises Directorate (SMED) to determine which program areas might hold records responsive to the request.
[17]SMED retrieved and provided the records it held in its information repositories and recommended that an additional tasking be sent to Legislative Policy and Regulatory Affairs Branch (LPRAB). However, no further potentially responsive records were located. The OIC’s investigation revealed that the OPIs most likely to have records relevant to the access request under their control searched for records in the appropriate repositories and used appropriate parameters. The OPIs provided all records to the Access to Information and Privacy unit for processing and the records responsive to the request were then provided to the complainant.
[18]To explain the number of records retrieved and processed, CRA represented that it does not approve trust companies, nor does it conduct enforcement actions, investigations, compliance reviews, or disciplinary measures related to TFSA or RRSP trustees. CRA also represented that it does not enforce trust law or otherwise regulate how trust companies administer registered plans.
[19]Furthermore, there was no evidence provided during the course of the investigation, which would lead the OIC to believe that additional records responsive to this access request exist.
[20]In light of the above, the OIC is satisfied that CRA conducted a reasonable search for records in response to the access request.
Outcome
[21]The complaint is not well founded.
Review by Federal Court
When an allegation in a complaint falls under paragraph 30(1)(a), (b), (c), (d), (d.1) or (e) of the Act, the complainant has the right to apply to the Federal Court for a review. The complainant must apply for this review within 35 business days after the date of this report and must serve a copy of the application for review to the relevant parties, as per section 43.